This Design Week article certainly cooked up a storm. And with good reason; it’s a sensitive subject. I responded, pointing out that whether or not these comments are ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ is only one question. We should also consider that they may represent a knee-jerk and poorly thought-out response to an issue that has many and complex causes, ranging from reforms in education to the global economic crisis. They don’t do the design industry justice in terms of its value as a profession. You can read my comment at the bottom of the article.
I have another newspaper article sitting on my desk, which coincidentally surfaced from D&AD’s archives a couple of weeks ago. It is entitled ‘Design Talent Faces Future on the Dole’, and was
written 24 years ago.
The parallels are quite remarkable.
Written by Michael Smith, the industrial editor of the Guardian, it talks about
the oversupply of talent to the industry and the risk of graduates
‘increasingly taking their talent overseas’. As long ago as 1985 the government
had produced something called the Verry-Pick report, which prompted this
article and according to Michael Smith ‘paints a disturbing picture of how
Britain neglects and underestimates the importance of designers’.
Here’s a couple more quotes from
the article that echo things we are hearing today in publications such as The
Cox Report:
‘If UK trade is to remain viable
and indeed if trade is to grow, the UK industrial trading sector must not
simply focus on costs, but must also turn its attention to the quality of the
goods it produces … [sectors] like design may account for up to half of a
nation’s successful trade performance … It is vital that Britain keeps pace
with developments elsewhere… It’s failure to do so will mean that markets will
disappear, exports will fall and import penetration will increase.’
In the light of all the talk about
markets like China and India, which seem to represent the same problem today as
was being faced in 1985, I wonder whether people think that progress was made,
or whether we are facing similar issues today because not enough was done back
then?
Laura Woodroffe, Education and Professional Development Director
Recent Comments